DCC and Sound in the Bachmann Climax



 
 
 

HOME

Construction
Articles

DCC
&Sound
Articles

PHOTOS

A Short
Story for
Children

Local
Railroad
Activities

S.R.M.
at the
W.D.M.

LINKS

Guest Book

e-mail us
 


Jim Banner, 27 July 1999 
This was not an easy engine to add both sound and digital command control to, but it was possible. Before starting, Scott and I reviewed George Schreyer's Digital Command Control Tips and his Bachmann Climax Tips in detail, then consulted the tables in his Tractive Effort Tests to help determine a suitable decoder. I also studied Ross Webster's DCC INSTALLATION IN THE BACHMANN CLIMAX and his Climax Modification to Pick-ups . While we did not follow them exactly, these articles were an excellent place to start.

The owner of the engine, Scott Gibb, had already purchased a Sierra sound card and had a spare MRC AD320 decoder on hand. He wanted to operate this engine on his garden railroad which is equipped with an MRC Command 2000 system complete with a 10 Amp booster. The decoder appeared to be a reasonable choice - the current draw of the Climax is similar to that of an Aristo-Craft RS-3 which our group has operated successfully for two years with one of these decoders.

But first, something definitely had to be done about power pickup. The wheel pickups in the Climax are fine but the pickups which transfer power from the trucks to the body are too light. These pickups work fine to transfer perhaps an amp from the trucks to the body for lighting and smoke generation. They fail quickly, however, when a truck-to-truck short occurs, such as derailing at a switch or accidentally straddling a power control gap in the rails. Scott's failed about five minutes out of the box, collapsing a spring and distorting the plastic around the pickup, when he tested his engine using a 10 amp DCC booster running in dc mode.

George Schreyer's solution is probably the best as by drilling through the "motor block piece" and adding new wires all the way to the ash pan, he avoids having wires that can move back and forth right next to a soldered joint, a sure source of trouble. Ross Webster's solution is easier, but leaves unsupported solder joints that may fail. Being Canadians, Scott and I compromised. We used Ross's solution, but added more wire to absorb the motion. At the rear truck, we wrapped the wires four turns around a 3/16" rod and tucked the resulting helix between the motor block piece and the floor of the tender. At the front, we ran the wires under the boiler in a longish hairpin arrangement. Unlike Ross, we soldered the wires to the ends of the semicircular plates at the same ends as the original wires.

While the trucks were apart, we lengthened the motor wires, unsoldering them from the clips and extending them with 24 ga. Teflon insulated wires and insulating the joints with shrink tubing. We momentarily connected the motor leads to a power supply to determine polarity, switching leads until the truck ran forward. Then we used orange wire for the positive lead, grey wire for the negative lead. We removed the wires from the original chuff switches and used one to pull the motor wires from the front truck through to the tender. (Later we used the other to pull the reed switch wires from the ash pan to the tender.) Being Teflon insulated, the wires slipped through easily.

Photo 1
Next came the power supply for the Sierra sound system. SoundTraxx recommends using a series resistor for voltages greater than 12 volts, but there was no one resistance which would be suitable over the entire output range of the Command 2000 booster. Therefore we decided to use a regulated power supply, based on a 7812 regulator. We mounted the regulator on the underside of the coal load by drilling and tapping a hole in the load. We used an insulator kit (mica washer and shoulder washer) plus some heat sink compound to keep the coal from becoming electrically hot while keeping the regulator from becoming thermally hot. In photo 1, the 7812 is at 2, the board supporting the bridge rectifier and fuse recommended by SoundTraxx is at 3, and the filter capacitor is at 1. Hidden under the masking tape seen above the power supply board in Photo 1 are the wires to a miniature toggle switch mounted in the water filler hatch.
 
 

figure 1
The regulated power supply circuit, shown at right, produces 11.3 volts d.c. for all output voltages from the Command 2000 booster. The additional diode in series with the output of the regulator prevents current feedback to the regulator via the charging circuit on the sound board.
 
 

Photo 2
Next we mounted the speaker and sound board following the instructions from SoundTraxx. Photo 2 shows the speaker mounted on two cardboard gaskets and the sound board prepared for mounting by the addition of two strips of SuperLock Fasteners to the back of the board behind the terminal strips. This allows the board to be mounted on the back wall of the tender with the push buttons accessible, yet the board can be easily removed. A bit of gentle prying with a tiny screwdriver inserted between the layers of SuperLock helps the joints to start splitting. A strip of SuperLock is seen at 1 in Photo 2.  At 2 is a remote volume control switch, a single pole, double throw, center-off miniature toggle switch which is spring loaded to center in both directions. With this switch, all sound board programming can be done without having to open the tender.

Photo 3
With the sound board in place, we mounted the AD320 decoder under the top of the tender using double sided foam tape. We filled the area between the four diodes with several layers of foam in order to give as large a mounting area as possible. In photo 3:
1 is the 7812 regulator
2 is the power supply board
3 is DCC decoder
4 is the sound board
5 is the power supply filter capacitor
6 is the volume control switch
7 is the loud speaker

We identified which of the two black conductors went to the right-hand wheels and marked it "red". Then we connected up the decoder and sound board as follows:
 
decoder wire
colour
sound board
terminal
function other connection
red n/c right-hand
wheels
power supply,
lights & smoke
black n/c left-hand
wheels
power supply,
lights & smoke
orange 7 motors
+
-
grey 8 motors
-
-
white +
yellow
13 bell
control
-
violet 14 whistle
control
-
blue n/c - -
green n/c - -
- 15 hiss
n/c
-
- 16 coupler
n/c
-
- 9 speaker -
- 10 speaker -
- 11 chuff 
switch
-
- 12 chuff
switch
-
-
micro plug
red wire
+11.3 from
power supply
-
- micro plug
black wire
-   return of
power supply
-

Because the MRC Command 2000 supports only two on-off functions, the lights in the Climax were left as originally connected. With DCC, this means they are on all the time. This frees up a channel to allow Scott to turn the bell on by turning the lights function on and to turn the bell off by turning the lights function off. He can also manually trigger the crossing whistle sequence by turning the auxiliary function on then off. This seemed a better choice than having the bell ringing every time the engine ran slow and having the whistle blow a crossing sequence every time the engine sped up. Scott has a coupler clank switch on order, so it will be installed at a later date.

We mounted the chuff reed switch according to the SoundTraxx directions, gluing it tight against the ashpan cover. The alnico magnets supplied with this switch were very much stronger than ceramic magnets so distance from magnet to switch was not an issue, but minimising the risk of snagging the switch and breaking it, was.

Photo 4
We managed to hide the on-off switch for the power supply in the water filler hatch and still have the hatch cover fit. We cut a circle of 1/16" styrene to be a tight fit in the filler tube and drilled an under sized hole through the center. Screwing the switch into the hole threaded it. There is no nut on top, but there is one under the styrene to help keep the switch from tipping when the toggle is thrown. In order to reinstall the hatch cover, we trimmed the inner cylinder of the cover flush with the outer one and trimmed the toggle to leave only 1/8" beyond the threaded mounting bushing. The switch body fits completely inside the tube with only the wires projecting into the inside of the tender.

figure 2
We test ran the engine for several days at this point. Everything seemed to be working well except the sound associated with starting and stopping - no blow down, no Fireman Fred, no stop whistle and no start whistle. Investigation indicated high frequency leakage through the decoder, probably capacitive coupling of the fast reversals of the DCC power through the decoder power transistors. A simple filter installed between the decoder motor wires and the Sierra sound board motor input terminals took care of the problem.

photo 5
We were fast running out of room and another board was out of the question, so we built the filter free form using compact 50 volt ceramic capacitors and 1/4 watt resistors . Photo 5 shows the filter sitting on a dime, just before it was encapsulated in shrink tubing. With the filter installed, both the sound system and DCC decoder worked as originally expected, with one exception - the engine gives two toots when starting forward, but it also gives two toots when starting backwards. At the moment, the cause of this is unknown, but it is something that we can live with.

Photo 6
With the tender reinstalled, the only visual give-away is the remote volume control switch toggle hanging below a corner of the tender. To our eyes, it looks like the engineer has added an extension to the tank drain valve to keep the sludge from splashing on his overalls. A piece of shrink tubing would make it look more like a piece of rubber hose stuck on the valve, but on this engine, all the engineer could lay his hands on was a piece of galvanized water pipe. At least that's our story, and we're sticking to it.


If you liked this article, let us know.  If you didn't, let us know why.  Your feedback helps us improve our site.

 


this page was last updated 4 January 2000